Wyatt Employment Law Report

Ten Largest Verdicts in Kentucky Employment Cases: 2000-2009

Leave a comment

By Patrick Schach

In the past decade, jury verdicts in employment cases have continued to grow across the country.  Kentucky is no different.  The ten largest non-Fair Labor Standards Act employment verdicts in Kentucky from 2000-2009 as reported in The Kentucky Trial Court Review Series, editions 3-12 are:

  • $4,352,316: Hill and Hill v. Kentucky Lottery (Jefferson, 2003):  Husband and wife employees received separate verdicts for $2,654,450 and $1,697,866 because of Defendant’s retaliation against them for helping a third employee’s discrimination claim.
  • $4,222,966: Jefferson v. Jefferson County Public Schools (Jefferson, 2004):  Elementary school teacher was accused of misconduct by her aide.  Jury found that school officials acted with malice when coercing plaintiff’s retirement.  Defendant’s tort was a denial of due process to plaintiff teacher.
  • $3,500,000:  Cobb v. Fayette County Board of Education et al (Fayette, 2005):  A middle school principal prevails on a whistleblower claim after reporting improprieties at her school.  The verdict included $1,000,000 in punitive damages against two individual school board officials.
  • $2,890,532:  Riles et al v. Kentucky Lottery (Jefferson, 2004):  Separate plaintiffs recovered $1,570,805 and $1,319,805 for different acts of racial discrimination.  After the first plaintiff quit her job because of the harassing work atmosphere, the second plaintiff was promoted and subsequently fired in a ruse to cover up the discrimination against the first plaintiff.
  • $2,000,002: Anderson & Vinson v. Dept. of Agriculture (Franklin, 2001):  In this whistleblower suit, Plaintiff supervisors succeeded after being retaliated against for reporting mismanagement in inspections.
  • $1,768,584:  Buckley v. Country Oven (Warren, 2002):  Employee at industrial bakery alleged employer required her to become a “snitch” as a condition of further employment.  When employee suffered physical and emotional injuries from this requirement, Defendant employer did not accommodate her disabilities.  Punitive damages of $1,250,000 were included in the verdict.
  • $1,461,744:  Breit and Walker v. Rawlings & Associates et al (Jefferson, 2002):  Two associate attorneys recovered individual verdicts of  $824,593 and $637,151 against their employer for failure to pay finder’s fees pursuant to an oral contract.  The verdict includes  $885,283 of punitive damages.
  • $1,281,363:  West v. Tyson Foods (Federal Court Owensboro, 2008):  Plaintiff employee prevailed in sexual harassment claim based on co-workers’ harassment and supervisor’s failure to take corrective action, instead telling plaintiff that the complained of behavior was simply “how Mexicans treat their women.”  The verdict included $400,000 of punitive damages.
  • $1,150,000: Younis v. Dept. of Homeland Security (Jefferson, 2006): Plaintiff TSA employee alleged sex discrimination based on inequities in pay between her and a male co-worker.  Plaintiff also alleged retaliation for raising the discrimination issue.  Jury sided with Defendant on discrimination issue but awarded plaintiff over one million dollars on the retaliation claim alone.
  • $1,086,750:  Clark v. KACo (Franklin, 2008):  Employee retaliated against by employer for her opposition to sexual harassment and prior participation in a third party’s lawsuit.

Leave a reply. Please note that although this blog may be helpful in informing clients and others who have an interest in information privacy and security, it is not intended to be legal advice. The information on this blog also should not be relied upon to form an attorney-client relationship.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s